4

I just noticed that we have a and tags. Should we keep them separate or should we make on a synonym of the other?

  • (Note that I have suggested an edit a few hours ago, so when it gets approved, no question will have the music-history tag anymore … for the moment.) – unor Feb 25 '15 at 15:59
9

I'd say we make a synonym of since this site is about music at it's core it's implied that most history questions will in some way be related to music.

  • If thy weren't related to music, they'd be off-topic anyway, so +1 from me. – Tetsujin Feb 26 '15 at 13:26
0

Caveat - this answer is about possible theoretical usage of tag, NOT about any questions that may or may not be currently covered by it today.

In my opinion, is a valid separate tag for very specific usage - that is, questions about music as it applies to/affects overall history (as opposed to history of music itself).

Example: questions like "effect of XYZ songs on morale of troops in WWII".

Litmus test is that usually, such questions might be on-topic on History.SE, but would be likely a better fit here, either because there are likely to be more topic experts on this site; or because they are insufficiently academically rigorous for History.SE's academic taste.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .